Loading trail…
Utah · Fishing
Fishing near Benson, Utah centers almost entirely on Cutler Reservoir, a broad, shallow impoundment on the Bear River that draws the bulk of local angling activity. Six of the seven listings in this area point to Cutler, which tells you something about where people actually spend their time.
7 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 7 spots
Fishing near Benson, Utah centers almost entirely on Cutler Reservoir, a broad, shallow impoundment on the Bear River that draws the bulk of local angling activity. Six of the seven listings in this area point to Cutler, which tells you something about where people actually spend their time. The reservoir sits in Cache Valley and is known for warm-water species rather than trout — expect carp, catfish, white bass, and black crappie depending on the season, with spring and early summer being the most productive windows before water temperatures climb. Pelican Pond rounds out the local options as a smaller, more contained lake-fishing spot that can be a quieter alternative when Cutler gets busy or when conditions on the bigger water are tough. Neither water is a destination fishery in the trophy sense, but both are accessible, low-pressure options for anglers who want to wet a line without a long drive. If you are coming specifically for Cutler Reservoir, a boat or kayak opens up significantly more of the water, though bank fishing is possible at several points around the reservoir.
Cutler Reservoir is a warm-water fishery, so you are looking at species like carp, channel catfish, white bass, and crappie rather than trout. The shallow, nutrient-rich water in Cache Valley supports these species well, particularly in spring and early summer when fish are more active near the surface and shoreline structure.
Spring through early summer is generally the most productive period, as water temperatures are rising and fish are feeding aggressively before the heat of July and August sets in. Early morning and evening outings tend to outperform midday fishing during warmer months when the sun is high and fish push deeper or into shade.
Blacksmith Fork Guard Station
~27 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cutler Reservoir
~1 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Egan Basin Guard Station
~46 min drive
A worthwhile stop near ID.
Cutler Reservoir
~2 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Tony Grove Lake
~29 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cutler Reservoir
~2 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cutler Reservoir
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cutler Reservoir
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cutler Reservoir
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cutler Reservoir
~4 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cutler Reservoir
~4 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cutler Reservoir
~7 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Bank fishing is possible at Cutler Reservoir, but a boat, kayak, or canoe gives you a real advantage given the size of the impoundment and the way fish spread out across the shallows. If you are fishing from shore, focus on areas near inflows, points, or any visible structure where fish are likely to concentrate.
For Cutler Reservoir, medium-weight spinning or baitcasting gear handles most of what you will encounter. Catfish anglers typically use cut bait or stink bait on the bottom, while crappie and white bass respond well to small jigs and spinners. At Pelican Pond, lighter tackle is usually sufficient given the smaller water and likely smaller fish.
Yes, a valid Utah fishing license is required for anyone 12 years of age or older fishing any public water in the state, including Cutler Reservoir and Pelican Pond. Licenses are available through the Utah Division of Wildlife Resources website or at local sporting goods retailers. Check the current Utah fishing regulations for any specific rules that apply to Cutler Reservoir before you go.
