Free — you'll pick up right here.
Watch this water
Sign up to watch it — saving subscribes you to gate, closure and report changes.
South Dakota
Horsethief Lake Fishing Site
We don't cover this water yet
No agency boundary, access route or field report is mapped to it — so there is no verdict, and we won't guess. We'll tell you the moment this water has something to say.
Covered nearby
Waters within 25 miles where we do have a current picture.
Nobody's filed a report here yet — be the first.
Here's your day on the water, mapped
Horsethief Lake Fishing Site
AI-suggested draft · review before you go
Gear for the day
Photos
Directions & GPX
About this water
Horsethief Lake Fishing Site is a lake fishing site in South Dakota, a U.S. Forest Service recreation site near Keystone. There is no fee.
Add to a trip & share
Keep exploring — more waters worth the drive
Sylvan Lake
~9 min drive
Sylvan Lake is an 18-acre reservoir in South Dakota.
Southern Hills - Custer
~18 min drive
A worthwhile stop near South Dakota.
Veterans Point Fishing Pier
~23 min drive
A worthwhile stop near South Dakota.
Sheridan Lake
~10 min drive
Sheridan Lake is a 372-acre reservoir in South Dakota.
Central Hills - Rapid City
~24 min drive
A worthwhile stop near South Dakota.
Stockade Lake
~15 min drive
Stockade Lake is a 127-acre reservoir in South Dakota.
Yate'S Pond
~59 min drive
A worthwhile stop near South Dakota.
Pactola Lake
~22 min drive
Pactola Lake is a 791-acre reservoir in South Dakota.
Shostak Reservoir
~1h 14m drive
Shostak Reservoir is a reservoir near Newcastle, Wyoming, at about 3,938 feet.
Angostura Reservoir
~1h 9m drive
Angostura Reservoir is a 4,005-acre reservoir in South Dakota.
Also worth it near here
