Loading trail…
Utah · Fishing
Marysvale sits in the Piute County stretch of south-central Utah, and the fishing here is quieter and more remote than what you'll find up near the Provo or Sevier river corridors.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Marysvale sits in the Piute County stretch of south-central Utah, and the fishing here is quieter and more remote than what you'll find up near the Provo or Sevier river corridors. The three lakes on the Roamze list — Lower Box Creek Reservoir, Upper Box Creek Reservoir, and Barney Lake — are all stillwater fisheries, which shapes everything about how you plan a trip. Expect dirt or gravel access roads that may require a high-clearance vehicle depending on the season, and don't count on cell service once you're out there. These are the kinds of waters where you might fish for a few hours without seeing another angler, which is either a selling point or a warning depending on your experience level. Because all three are reservoirs or mountain lakes rather than rivers, the fishing rhythm follows water temperature and elevation more than hatch charts. Early summer and early fall tend to be the most productive windows, after spring runoff settles and before late-season drawdowns affect water levels. If you're driving up from Marysvale town, build in extra time for the approach — these aren't roadside pullover spots.
All three waters listed — Lower Box Creek Reservoir, Upper Box Creek Reservoir, and Barney Lake — are stillwater fisheries, meaning lake and reservoir fishing rather than stream or river fishing. You'll be casting from shore or a small watercraft rather than wading a current.
Yes. A valid Utah fishing license is required to fish any of these waters. Licenses are available through the Utah Division of Wildlife Resources website or at local sporting goods retailers. Check the current year's regulations booklet for any site-specific rules before you go.
Mackinaw
~30 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Adelaide Campground
~46 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Koosharem Day Use site
~22 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Frying Pan
~36 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Maple Grove
~1h 3m drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Otter Creek, Tamarisk Point Rec Site
~32 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Gooseberry Admin Site Cabins
~49 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Cowpuncher Guard Station
~1h 6m drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Otter Creek, Fishermans Beach Rec Site
~35 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Aquarius Ranger Station
~54 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Fremont River Ranger District
~51 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
Otter Creek, South Point Recreation Site
~36 min drive
A worthwhile stop near UT.
For stillwater fishing at elevation, early morning is generally the most productive window — water temperatures are cooler and fish tend to be more active near the surface. Late afternoon can also pick up, especially in summer when midday heat pushes fish deeper.
A medium-light spinning setup covers most situations on these lakes. Bring a selection of small spoons, inline spinners, and PowerBait-style offerings for shore fishing. If you have a float tube or small inflatable, it'll open up water that shore anglers can't reach. Pack out everything you bring in — these are dispersed recreation areas without trash service.
The fishing itself is beginner-friendly — stillwater fishing is generally more forgiving than reading moving water. The main consideration is the drive in, which may involve unpaved roads that aren't suitable for low-clearance vehicles or trailers. Confirm road conditions locally before heading out, particularly in early spring or after heavy rain.
