Loading trail…
New Jersey · Fishing
Stillwater Township sits in Sussex County, in the northwestern corner of New Jersey, and the fishing here centers on a handful of quiet lakes tucked into the Kittatinny Valley.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Stillwater Township sits in Sussex County, in the northwestern corner of New Jersey, and the fishing here centers on a handful of quiet lakes tucked into the Kittatinny Valley. Fairview Lake and Plymouth Pond are the two waters you'll be working with, both offering lake fishing in a setting that stays relatively uncrowded compared to the more trafficked reservoirs closer to the metro area. Fairview Lake is the larger and better-known of the two, with shoreline access that works for anglers who don't have a boat, though a small watercraft opens up more of the structure. Plymouth Pond is a smaller, calmer option that suits beginners or anyone looking for a low-key morning on the water. Both lakes hold warmwater species typical of Sussex County — expect largemouth bass, panfish like bluegill and crappie, and chain pickerel. Neither water appears on New Jersey's list of gold medal or wild trout designations, so manage expectations on the trout front outside of stocked seasons. Spring and fall are the most productive windows overall, when water temperatures push fish into shallower, more accessible zones. If you're driving in, Stillwater Township is roughly 60 miles west of New York City, so an early start is worth it to beat any weekend traffic.
Both lakes support warmwater species common to Sussex County, including largemouth bass, chain pickerel, bluegill, and crappie. Neither lake is designated a gold medal or wild trout water, so trout fishing is dependent on New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife stocking schedules rather than a self-sustaining population.
Yes. New Jersey requires a valid state fishing license for anyone 16 and older. You can purchase one online through the New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife or at local license agents. If you're fishing during trout season, check whether a separate trout stamp is required for the specific water and time of year.
Alosa Campsites
~7 min drive
A worthwhile stop near PA.
Flatbrook - Flatbrookville Access
~1 min drive
Moderate
Fairview Lake
~2 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Paulinskill River - Blairstown Access
~13 min drive
Easy
Long Pine Pond
~2 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Fairview Lake
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Blue Mountain Lakes
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Plymouth Pond
~5 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Sand Pond
~5 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Lower Crandon Lake
~6 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Meadows Lake
~7 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Mud Pond
~8 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Early morning, roughly the first two hours after sunrise, is consistently the most productive window for bass and pickerel at both lakes. Evening before sunset is a close second, especially in summer when midday heat pushes fish deeper and off the bite.
A medium-light to medium spinning setup covers most situations at both lakes. For bass and pickerel, soft plastics, spinnerbaits, and shallow-running crankbaits work well along weed edges and any visible structure. For panfish, a simple bobber-and-worm rig is hard to beat. A small kayak or canoe is useful at Fairview Lake to reach water away from the bank, but shore fishing is viable.
Plymouth Pond in particular is a good fit for beginners and younger anglers given its smaller, calmer nature and the abundance of panfish, which are easier to target and catch consistently. Fairview Lake has more variety and water to explore but is still approachable for anyone with basic fishing experience.
