New Jersey · Fishing
Fishing in Kinnelon, New Jersey
Kinnelon sits in the Morris County highlands of New Jersey, and its fishing scene is built around still water — specifically the three reservoirs and ponds that make up the local options: Sawmill Pond, Macopin Reservoir, and Taylortown Reservoir.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
Kinnelon sits in the Morris County highlands of New Jersey, and its fishing scene is built around still water — specifically the three reservoirs and ponds that make up the local options: Sawmill Pond, Macopin Reservoir, and Taylortown Reservoir. These are quiet, accessible lake-fishing spots rather than destination trophy waters, which makes them a solid choice for anglers who want to get a line in without a long drive or a boat ramp circus. Sawmill Pond tends to draw casual anglers and families given its smaller size and easier shoreline access. Macopin and Taylortown are reservoir settings, which typically means cleaner water, some depth variation, and the kind of structure that holds fish through the warmer months. New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife manages stocking programs across the state, so checking the current stocking report before your trip is worth the two minutes it takes. A valid New Jersey fishing license is required for anyone 16 and older. None of these waters carry a gold-medal or wild-trout designation, so set expectations accordingly — this is solid local fishing, not a bucket-list destination.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a fishing license to fish Sawmill Pond, Macopin Reservoir, or Taylortown Reservoir?
Yes. Any angler 16 or older needs a valid New Jersey fishing license. You can purchase one online through the NJ Division of Fish and Wildlife or at most local sporting goods retailers. Check whether the specific reservoir you're targeting requires any additional access permit, since some reservoir properties in New Jersey have their own rules layered on top of the state license.
What species can I expect to catch at these waters?
Reservoir and pond fishing in this part of Morris County typically produces largemouth bass, bluegill, and chain pickerel as year-round residents. New Jersey's stocking program adds trout — usually rainbow trout — to eligible waters in spring and fall. Check the NJ Fish and Wildlife stocking report close to your trip date to see whether Macopin or Taylortown are on the current schedule.
What time of day is best for fishing these spots?
Early morning and the last two hours before sunset are consistently the most productive windows for bass and pickerel in still water. Trout stocked in spring tend to be more active during cooler midday hours early in the season before water temperatures climb. Midday in July and August is generally the slowest period across all three locations.
What gear should I bring for lake fishing in Kinnelon?
A medium-light spinning setup in the 6- to 7-foot range covers most situations across these waters. For bass and pickerel, soft plastics, small spinnerbaits, and inline spinners all work well around structure and weed edges. If you're targeting stocked trout, a simple bobber-and-worm rig or small spoons are reliable. Bring polarized sunglasses — they help you read the water and spot structure from the bank.
Can I fish from a boat, or is this shore fishing only?
Access rules vary by water body. Sawmill Pond is generally shore-accessible, but Macopin and Taylortown are reservoir properties that may restrict or prohibit motorized boats and have specific access points. Contact the relevant managing authority — either the borough or the water utility that owns the reservoir — before showing up with a kayak or canoe to confirm what's permitted.
