Loading trail…
New Jersey · Fishing
Blairstown sits in Warren County at the edge of the Kittatinny Ridge, and the fishing here reflects that geography — cold-water streams, reservoir edges, and the kind of unhurried pace that makes a half-day on the water feel worthwhile.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Blairstown sits in Warren County at the edge of the Kittatinny Ridge, and the fishing here reflects that geography — cold-water streams, reservoir edges, and the kind of unhurried pace that makes a half-day on the water feel worthwhile. The Paulinskill River at the Blairstown Access is the most technically interesting option in town, a river stretch at 580 feet elevation where fly anglers can work for rainbow, brown, and brook trout on water that's rated accessible enough for beginners but still holds fish worth chasing. Lake Genevieve and Lower Yards Creek Reservoir round out the local options with lake fishing that suits spin anglers and those who'd rather set up on a bank than wade a current. None of these are destination fisheries that draw crowds from three states over, but that's part of the appeal — you're not fighting for elbow room on the Paulinskill the way you would on more heavily promoted trout water. If you're driving up from the New York metro area or passing through on a Delaware Water Gap trip, Blairstown's access points are easy to work into a day without a lot of planning overhead.
The Paulinskill River at the Blairstown Access holds rainbow trout, brown trout, and brook trout. Lake Genevieve and Lower Yards Creek Reservoir are listed as lake fishing spots, but the available data doesn't specify target species for those two — contact the New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife or check their stocking reports before making either lake your primary destination.
Yes — the Blairstown Access stretch is rated easy difficulty, and the river at 580 feet elevation is a manageable wade for someone still building confidence. That said, 'easy' refers to access and wading conditions, not guaranteed fish counts, so bring a range of nymph and dry fly patterns and be prepared to read the water.
Alosa Campsites
~10 min drive
A worthwhile stop near PA.
Lake Genevieve
~1 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Paulinskill River - Blairstown Access
~3 min drive
Easy
Flatbrook - Flatbrookville Access
~13 min drive
Moderate
Spring Valley Lake
~4 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Pequest River - Pequest Trout Hatchery Access
~13 min drive
Easy
Brodhead Creek - Analomink Section
~23 min drive
Moderate
Lower Yards Creek Reservoir
~4 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Musconetcong River - Stephens State Park
~24 min drive
Easy
Meadows Lake
~6 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Mud Pond
~7 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Sand Pond
~8 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NJ.
Trout season in New Jersey typically opens in early April, and the Paulinskill fishes well through spring when water temperatures are still cold. Summer heat can push water temps up and stress trout, so early morning outings matter more in July and August. Fall is often underrated — cooler temps return, crowds thin out, and brown trout in particular become more active.
A 9-foot, 5-weight rod is a practical all-around choice for this type of river water. Bring waders and wading boots since you'll want to get into position on the current. A New Jersey freshwater fishing license is required, and trout require a separate trout stamp — purchase both through the NJ Division of Fish and Wildlife before you arrive.
The Paulinskill River listing specifically calls out a named access point — Blairstown Access — which suggests designated public entry rather than a scramble through private land. For Lake Genevieve and Lower Yards Creek Reservoir, verify access and any permit requirements locally before your trip, as reservoir access rules in New Jersey can vary by managing authority.
