Loading trail…
Montana · Fishing
Fishing around Gardiner, Montana centers on lake fishing, with the Gardiner District offering access to several alpine and backcountry lakes including Castle Lake and Shelf Lake.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Fishing around Gardiner, Montana centers on lake fishing, with the Gardiner District offering access to several alpine and backcountry lakes including Castle Lake and Shelf Lake. This is not a float-trip-and-dry-fly destination in the traditional sense — the lakes here tend to reward anglers who are willing to hike in, pack light, and fish water that doesn't see heavy pressure. Proximity to Yellowstone National Park shapes a lot of the logistics: park boundary regulations are strict and separate from Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks rules, so knowing exactly which side of the line you're on matters before you wet a line. The Gardiner area sits at the northern entrance to Yellowstone, which means shoulder seasons can be short and mountain weather moves fast. That said, summer lake fishing here can be genuinely productive for anglers who time their trips around ice-out and early morning windows before afternoon winds pick up. If you're driving up from Livingston or flying into Bozeman, Gardiner is roughly 80 miles south — plan on a full day at minimum for any lake that requires a trail approach.
If the lakes are located within Montana and outside Yellowstone National Park boundaries, you need a valid Montana fishing license. If any of these waters fall inside the park, you need a Yellowstone National Park fishing permit instead — not a Montana license. Check the exact coordinates of your destination against park boundary maps before you go, because the boundary near Gardiner is not always obvious on the ground.
The activity listings for this area specify lake fishing but do not include species data, so we won't guess. Your best source is Montana FWP's online fishing access site, which lists stocked and native species by water body, or a call to the Gardiner-area FWP office before your trip.
Big Creek Cabin
~29 min drive
A worthwhile stop near MT.
Window Rock Cabin
~47 min drive
A worthwhile stop near MT.
Gallatin River - Greek Creek Access
~55 min drive
Moderate
Fisherman's Point
~56 min drive
A worthwhile stop near MT.
Mill Creek Cabin
~31 min drive
A worthwhile stop near MT.
Maxey Cabin
~48 min drive
A worthwhile stop near MT.
Fox Creek Cabin
~51 min drive
A worthwhile stop near MT.
Lake Yellowstone Hotel and Cabins
~1h 11m drive
A worthwhile stop near WY.
Beaver Creek Cabin
~53 min drive
A worthwhile stop near MT.
Old Faithful Inn
~1h 15m drive
A worthwhile stop near WY.
Fourmile Cabin
~55 min drive
A worthwhile stop near MT.
Big Springs Grp. Area - Island Park
~1h 21m drive
A worthwhile stop near ID.
Alpine lakes in this part of Montana are typically ice-free from late June through September, though that window shifts depending on snowpack and elevation. Ice-out and the weeks immediately following are often the most productive period. By late summer, water temperatures stabilize and fishing can slow midday, making early morning the most reliable window.
The listings do not include trail-distance or road-access details, so we can't give you exact mileage. Lakes named Shelf Lake and Castle Lake in Montana backcountry contexts typically require at least a moderate hike on unmaintained or lightly maintained trails. Check current trail conditions with the Gallatin National Forest or Yellowstone's backcountry office depending on which jurisdiction applies.
A light to medium spinning setup or a 4- to 6-weight fly rod covers most alpine lake situations. Pack for wind — open lakes at elevation get gusty by early afternoon. Bring a valid license, a way to store and pack out any harvest, and layers regardless of the forecast. If you're hiking in, keep your tackle selection minimal and weight-conscious.
