Loading trail…
New York · Fishing
Southold sits on the North Fork of Long Island, where the fishing tends to be quieter and more accessible than the crowded South Shore scene.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Southold sits on the North Fork of Long Island, where the fishing tends to be quieter and more accessible than the crowded South Shore scene. The three freshwater spots listed here — Great Pond, Richmond Creek, and Hashamomuck Pond — are all lake and pond fisheries, meaning you're working relatively calm, sheltered water rather than surf or open bay. That makes Southold's freshwater fishing a reasonable option for anglers of most skill levels, including those new to the sport or fishing with kids. Great Pond and Hashamomuck Pond are true stillwater environments, good for working the shoreline or a small kayak or canoe. Richmond Creek is listed under lake fishing as well, suggesting slower, pond-like conditions rather than a fast-moving stream. Spring and fall are typically the most productive seasons for freshwater fishing on Long Island, when water temperatures are in a range that keeps fish actively feeding. Summer can still produce, especially early morning or in the evening when surface temperatures drop. Access to these spots varies, so it's worth checking current New York State DEC guidance on public fishing rights before you go.
The listed spots — Great Pond, Richmond Creek, and Hashamomuck Pond — are all freshwater lake and pond fisheries. You're not looking at surf fishing or saltwater access here; this is calm, stillwater fishing suited to light tackle, spinning gear, or fly fishing from the bank or a small watercraft.
Yes. New York State requires a freshwater fishing license for anyone 16 or older. You can purchase one through the New York State DEC website or at local license agents. Check the DEC site for any site-specific regulations before heading out, as access rules can vary by water body.
Richmond Creek
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NY.
Great Pond
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NY.
Hashamomuck Pond
~4 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NY.
Willow Pond
~9 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NY.
Short Bay
~12 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NY.
Crooked Pond
~17 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NY.
Scoy Pond
~18 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NY.
Old Rock Pond
~27 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CT.
Old Rock Pond
~27 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CT.
Home Pond
~28 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NY.
Indian Lake
~28 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CT.
Chapman Mill Pond
~28 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CT.
Spring (April through early June) and fall (September through October) are generally the most productive windows for freshwater fishing on Long Island. Water temperatures during those periods keep fish feeding more actively. Summer fishing can still work, but plan to be on the water at first light or in the last hour before dark to avoid the midday heat slowdown.
Light to medium spinning tackle is a practical all-around choice for pond and lake fishing in this area. A 6- to 7-foot rod with 6- to 10-pound monofilament or light braid covers most situations. Bring a selection of soft plastics, small spinners, and live bait rigs. A kayak or canoe can open up more of the water at Great Pond and Hashamomuck Pond, though confirm whether motorized boats are permitted before you launch.
Yes, pond and lake fishing in calm, sheltered water is one of the more forgiving environments to learn in. The stillwater conditions at these three spots mean you're not dealing with current or surf, which simplifies casting and line management. Younger kids tend to do well with a simple bobber-and-worm setup along the shoreline.
