Loading trail…
New Mexico · Fishing
Maxwell, New Mexico sits in the northeastern corner of the state where the high plains meet the foothills of the Sangre de Cristo Mountains, and the fishing here is almost entirely built around a cluster of small lakes on what was historically the Maxwell Land Grant.
5 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 5 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Maxwell, New Mexico sits in the northeastern corner of the state where the high plains meet the foothills of the Sangre de Cristo Mountains, and the fishing here is almost entirely built around a cluster of small lakes on what was historically the Maxwell Land Grant. Number Eleven Lake, Number Twelve Lake, Number Thirteen Lake, Number Twenty Lake, and Stubblefield Reservoir make up the fishable waters in and around town — all of them lake fishing, no river runs or stream access in this particular lineup. These are relatively compact, quiet waters that don't draw the crowds you'd find at Cimarron Canyon or Eagle Nest Lake to the west, which is part of the appeal. The lakes sit at elevation and can fish well in spring and fall when temperatures are moderate. If you're driving up from Raton or down from Colorado on US-64, Maxwell is a low-key stop that rewards anglers willing to do a little homework on access and current conditions before showing up. New Mexico Game and Fish regulations apply, and a valid New Mexico fishing license is required for anyone 18 and older.
The activity listings cover lake fishing across Number Eleven, Twelve, Thirteen, Twenty, and Stubblefield Reservoir, but don't specify species by water body. Your best move before the trip is to check the New Mexico Game and Fish Department website, which publishes stocking reports by water body and will tell you exactly what's been put in and when.
Spring (April through early June) and fall (September through October) tend to be the most productive seasons for high-plains lakes in northeastern New Mexico. Summer afternoons get hot and windy, which pushes fish deeper and makes surface conditions rough. Early mornings are your best window in summer if you're committed to fishing that time of year.
Number Twelve Lake
~1 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Charette Lakes
~35 min drive
Easy
Cabresto Lake
~1h 16m drive
Moderate
Goose Lake Fishing
~1h 21m drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Number Eleven Lake
~2 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Red River - Main Street Access
~1h 18m drive
Easy
Number Thirteen Lake
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Number Twenty Lake
~4 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Stubblefield Reservoir
~6 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Koehler Lake
~19 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Big Lake
~38 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Ferguson Lake
~38 min drive
A worthwhile stop near NM.
Also worth it near here
Access to the numbered lakes around Maxwell is not universally open — some waters in this area sit on private or managed land and may require a permit or fee. Contact the New Mexico Game and Fish Department or Colfax County offices ahead of your trip to confirm current public access status for each specific lake, especially Stubblefield Reservoir.
A medium-light spinning setup handles most situations on these smaller lakes. Bring a range of options — small jigs, inline spinners, PowerBait-style dough baits, and a few live-bait rigs cover the bases whether you're targeting stocked fish or whatever's holding near structure. A small tackle box beats hauling a full kit to waters of this size.
Yes, a valid New Mexico fishing license is required for anyone 18 or older. You can buy one online through the New Mexico Game and Fish Department website, at a licensed vendor in Raton (the nearest larger town), or through the department's phone system. Buy it before you leave home to avoid scrambling for a vendor in a small town.
