Idaho · Fishing
Fishing in McCall, Idaho
McCall sits at the edge of Payette Lake, and the fishing around town reflects that geography — still water, moving water, and a handful of smaller reservoirs all within a short drive.
8 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 8 spots
McCall sits at the edge of Payette Lake, and the fishing around town reflects that geography — still water, moving water, and a handful of smaller reservoirs all within a short drive. Payette Lake itself is the obvious anchor, a deep mountain lake where you can fish from shore or by boat depending on how you want to spend the day. If you prefer moving water, the Upper Payette Lake Campground area puts you on the river, which fishes differently and rewards a different approach. Boulder Meadows Reservoir and Boulder Lake are worth the extra miles for anglers who want to get away from the main lake crowds, while Lower Jug Creek Reservoir is a quieter option closer in. The North Fork Payette Rec Site rounds out the options with surf fishing access on moving water. None of these are stocked trophy fisheries with special designations in our listings, so set expectations accordingly — this is solid mountain fishing in a genuinely beautiful setting, not a destination built around record catches. That said, the variety of water types means you can match the outing to your skill level and gear, whether you're wading a river stretch or drifting a fly across a reservoir at dusk.
Frequently asked questions
What types of water can I fish near McCall?
You have a good mix. Payette Lake is the largest option and offers lake fishing from multiple access points. Boulder Meadows Reservoir, Lower Jug Creek Reservoir, and Boulder Lake are smaller still-water options. For moving water, the Upper Payette Lake Campground area and the North Fork Payette Rec Site both offer river fishing.
Do I need a fishing license to fish in McCall?
Yes, an Idaho fishing license is required for anyone 14 and older. You can purchase one online through the Idaho Department of Fish and Game or at local sporting goods stores in McCall. Check current regulations before you go, since rules around seasons and bag limits can vary by water body.
What is the best time of day to fish Payette Lake?
Early morning and the hour or two before sunset are generally the most productive windows on mountain lakes like Payette. Midday sun pushes fish deeper, especially in summer. If you're fishing the river sections near Upper Payette Lake Campground, early morning is also your best bet before foot traffic picks up.
Are the smaller reservoirs like Boulder Meadows and Lower Jug Creek accessible without a high-clearance vehicle?
Road conditions to the more remote reservoirs, including Boulder Meadows, can be rough and are worth confirming before you go, especially early in the season when roads may still be soft or partially closed. Lower Jug Creek Reservoir is closer in and generally more accessible. Calling the Payette National Forest office in McCall is the most reliable way to get current road status.
Is the fishing around McCall suitable for beginners?
Yes, particularly on Payette Lake, where shore fishing is straightforward and you do not need specialized gear or wading experience. The smaller reservoirs are also beginner-friendly. The river sections at Upper Payette Lake Campground and the North Fork Payette Rec Site involve moving water, which adds some complexity but is still manageable for anglers with basic casting skills.
