Loading trail…
South Dakota · Fishing
Lake City sits in the glacial lake country of northeastern South Dakota, and the fishing around town reflects that geography — a cluster of natural lakes within easy reach of each other, each with its own character.
6 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 6 spots
Lake City sits in the glacial lake country of northeastern South Dakota, and the fishing around town reflects that geography — a cluster of natural lakes within easy reach of each other, each with its own character. Horseshoe Lake, Simmon Lake, Crystal Lake, Turtlefoot Lake, Goose Lake, and Fourmile Lake all offer lake fishing, and the fact that you can work through several of them in a single trip is one of the practical advantages of basing yourself here. This part of South Dakota is walleye and perch territory by default, with northern pike showing up in most of the shallower, weedier lakes in the area. None of these are destination trophy fisheries with national reputations, but they're productive, accessible, and rarely crowded the way the bigger reservoirs get. If you're driving up from Watertown or over from Aberdeen, the combination of lakes here makes it worth a full weekend rather than a day trip. Expect to do some scouting — smaller glacial lakes can fish very differently from one another depending on depth, weed structure, and recent weather — but that's part of what makes working through a group of lakes like this genuinely interesting rather than just repetitive.
Walleye and yellow perch are the most consistent targets across lakes like Horseshoe, Crystal, and Fourmile in this part of northeastern South Dakota. Northern pike are common in shallower, weedier lakes such as Goose Lake and Turtlefoot Lake. Bluegill and crappie turn up as well, particularly in warmer months when they move into shallower structure.
Early spring just after ice-out and late fall before freeze-up tend to produce the most active walleye and pike fishing, when fish are in shallower water and feeding aggressively. Summer perch fishing holds up well through the warmer months, especially early morning and evening when surface temperatures cool. Ice fishing in winter is popular on these lakes and can be productive for perch and walleye once safe ice forms.
Fourmile Lake
~5 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Waubay Lake
~44 min drive
Moderate
Hoop Lake
~6 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Lost Lake
~7 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Simmon Lake
~7 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Crystal Lake
~8 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Goodbird Lake
~9 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Horseshoe Lake
~10 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Horseshoe Lake
~10 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Goodbird Lake
~10 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Cottonwood Lake
~10 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Turtlefoot Lake
~10 min drive
A worthwhile stop near SD.
Yes, a valid South Dakota fishing license is required to fish any of these lakes. You can purchase one online through the South Dakota Game, Fish and Parks website or at local bait and sporting goods shops in the region. Non-resident licenses are available, and there are both annual and short-term options depending on the length of your trip.
A medium-action spinning rod in the 6- to 7-foot range covers most situations across these lakes. For walleye, jigs tipped with live minnows or crawlers are reliable, and a slip-bobber rig works well in calmer conditions. Pike anglers should bring wire leaders and larger spoons or swimbaits. For perch, lighter tackle with small jigs or live bait under a bobber is the straightforward approach.
Shore access varies by lake, and a boat or kayak will open up significantly more water on most of these glacial lakes, where the productive weed edges and drop-offs are often out of comfortable casting range from shore. That said, smaller lakes like Turtlefoot and Goose can be fishable from shore at the right access points, particularly in spring when fish are in close. Check with South Dakota GFP for current public access information on each specific lake before you go.
