New Jersey · Fishing
Fishing in Sandyston, New Jersey
Sandyston Township sits in the far northwest corner of New Jersey, tucked inside Sussex County where the Kittatinny Ridge runs along the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area.
4 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 4 spots
Sandyston Township sits in the far northwest corner of New Jersey, tucked inside Sussex County where the Kittatinny Ridge runs along the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area. The fishing here is almost entirely lake and pond-based, with four still-water options in the immediate area: Deer Lake, Kittatinny Lake, Kittatinny Camp Lake, and Shotwell Pond. These are quiet, relatively small bodies of water that tend to hold warmwater species like largemouth bass, bluegill, and chain pickerel, along with seasonal trout stocking that New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife runs each spring. None of these waters appear on the state's wild trout or Category One lists, so expect stocked fish rather than a self-sustaining wild population. That said, Kittatinny Lake in particular has a long history as a recreational fishing destination given its size and the camps that have operated on its shores for decades. Access points vary by water body, and some of the camp lakes have restricted public access, so confirming current public entry before you drive out is worth the five-minute phone call. A canoe, kayak, or small electric-motor boat will open up more of these lakes than bank fishing alone, especially on Kittatinny Lake where the shoreline can be heavily vegetated in summer.
Frequently asked questions
What fish species can I expect to catch at these Sandyston lakes?
Largemouth bass, chain pickerel, bluegill, and yellow perch are the most common warmwater species across Deer Lake, Kittatinny Lake, Shotwell Pond, and Kittatinny Camp Lake. Rainbow and brown trout are stocked by the state in spring, typically from late March through April, but they are not wild-reproducing fish in these waters.
Is Kittatinny Camp Lake open to the public?
Kittatinny Camp Lake is associated with a camp facility, which means public access is not guaranteed year-round. Contact the Sussex County or the camp operator directly before visiting to confirm whether walk-in or boat access is permitted on the dates you plan to fish.
Do I need a New Jersey fishing license to fish here?
Yes. Anyone 16 or older needs a valid New Jersey freshwater fishing license to fish any of these waters. If you plan to keep trout during the stocked season, you also need a separate trout stamp. Licenses are available through the NJ Division of Fish and Wildlife website or at local sporting goods retailers.
What time of day is best for fishing these lakes?
Early morning from first light until about 9 a.m. is consistently the most productive window for bass and pickerel, especially in summer when midday water temperatures push fish into deeper, shadier areas. A second window in the last two hours before sunset can also be reliable. During spring trout season, timing matters less since stocked fish are more active throughout the day shortly after a stocking event.
What gear setup works well for these still-water fisheries?
A medium-light to medium spinning rod in the 6- to 7-foot range handles most situations across these lakes and ponds. For bass and pickerel, soft plastics, small spinnerbaits, and weedless rigs work well given the vegetation common in these waters. If you are targeting trout during the spring stocking period, a simple slip-sinker rig with a PowerBait or small inline spinner is effective from the bank.
