Missouri · Fishing
Fishing in St. Joseph, Missouri
St. Joseph sits along the Missouri River, but the fishing most locals actually rely on happens in the lakes scattered through and around the city. New Mud Lake, Horseshoe Lake, and Lake Contrary are the three main options here, all offering lake fishing without the logistics of river access.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
St. Joseph sits along the Missouri River, but the fishing most locals actually rely on happens in the lakes scattered through and around the city. New Mud Lake, Horseshoe Lake, and Lake Contrary are the three main options here, all offering lake fishing without the logistics of river access. Lake Contrary is the largest and most developed of the three, with paved parking and accessible bank fishing spots that make it a reasonable choice for anglers of most skill levels. Horseshoe Lake and New Mud Lake are smaller and quieter, the kind of spots where you can show up on a weekday morning and have a bank to yourself. All three are warmwater lakes, so expect species like largemouth bass, channel catfish, bluegill, and crappie rather than trout. Missouri Department of Conservation manages fishing regulations statewide, so a valid Missouri fishing permit is required for anyone 16 and older regardless of which lake you fish. The city's lake fishing is genuinely accessible for beginners, but experienced anglers who work structure and time their trips around low-light windows will consistently do better.
Frequently asked questions
What fish species can I expect to catch at St. Joseph's lakes?
New Mud Lake, Horseshoe Lake, and Lake Contrary are all warmwater fisheries. You're most likely to encounter largemouth bass, channel catfish, bluegill, and crappie. None of these lakes are designated trout or cold-water fisheries, so plan your gear and techniques accordingly.
Do I need a fishing license to fish Lake Contrary or the other lakes here?
Yes. Missouri requires a valid fishing permit for anyone age 16 or older. You can purchase one through the Missouri Department of Conservation's website or at local retailers. Have it on you when you fish — conservation agents do check.
What's the best time of day to fish these lakes?
Early morning and the hour or two before sunset are consistently the most productive windows for bass and crappie in warmwater lakes like these. Catfish tend to bite well into the evening and overnight, especially in warmer months when they're actively feeding along the bottom.
What gear should I bring for lake fishing in St. Joseph?
A medium-action spinning rod handles most situations across all three lakes. For bass, soft plastics and shallow-running crankbaits work well around structure. For catfish, a heavier setup with cut bait or chicken liver on the bottom is the standard approach. Bluegill and crappie respond well to small jigs and live worms under a bobber.
Are these lakes accessible for beginners or families with kids?
Lake Contrary in particular has accessible bank fishing with parking nearby, making it the most practical choice for families or anyone who doesn't want to hike to the water. Horseshoe Lake and New Mud Lake are also walkable and don't require a boat. All three are low-pressure enough that a beginner can fish comfortably without feeling crowded out.
