Loading trail…
Indiana · Fishing
Brookville, Indiana sits at the center of one of the state's more productive fishing setups, anchored by Brookville Lake and the tailwater stretch below the dam. The lake itself draws anglers to spots like the Mounds Area, where lake fishing for a mix of warm-water species is the main draw.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Brookville, Indiana sits at the center of one of the state's more productive fishing setups, anchored by Brookville Lake and the tailwater stretch below the dam. The lake itself draws anglers to spots like the Mounds Area, where lake fishing for a mix of warm-water species is the main draw. Below the dam, the two Tailwater Shelters — Tailwater Shelter 1 and Tailwater Shelter 2 — give you access to river fishing in the outflow, which tends to fish differently than the lake and often holds fish that move up from the main pool. Between the lake and the tailwater, you have two distinct fishing experiences within a short drive of each other, which makes Brookville worth a dedicated trip rather than just a day stop. The shelters also provide covered access points, which matters when weather moves in or when you want a shaded spot during a long summer session. Whether you're working the lake from shore at the Mounds Area or dropping a line in the current below the dam, the variety here is the real selling point.
The Tailwater Shelters sit below Brookville Lake's dam and offer river fishing in moving water, where current and dam releases influence fish behavior and positioning. The Mounds Area is a lake fishing spot on Brookville Lake itself, with calmer water and a different set of species and techniques. If you want to work both in one trip, they are close enough to do so without much driving.
Brookville Lake is a warm-water reservoir, so expect largemouth bass, crappie, bluegill, and catfish as the primary targets. The tailwater stretch below the dam can hold different fish depending on what moves through the outflow, including species that favor cooler, oxygenated moving water. Check the Indiana DNR's current stocking and regulation reports before your trip for the most accurate species information.
Tailwater Shelter 1 (brookville Lake)
~2 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Mounds Area
~5 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Tailwater Shelter 2 (brookville Lake)
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Brookville Lake
~13 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Caesar Creek Lake
~1h 25m drive
A worthwhile stop near OH.
Whitewater Lake
~19 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Winton Woods
~49 min drive
A worthwhile stop near OH.
Woodland Retreat Lake
~26 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Visitor Center Day Use Rec Site
~1h 25m drive
A worthwhile stop near OH.
Miami Whitewater Forest Lake
~33 min drive
A worthwhile stop near OH.
Greenbriar Lake
~37 min drive
A worthwhile stop near OH.
Mystic Lake
~40 min drive
A worthwhile stop near OH.
Yes, a valid Indiana fishing license is required at all three locations. Brookville Lake falls under standard Indiana DNR regulations, and the tailwater area below the dam may have specific rules around the dam structure itself. Review the current Indiana DNR fishing guide for any size or bag limits that apply to the species you are targeting.
Early morning and late evening are generally the most productive windows for the tailwater stretch, especially in summer when midday heat pushes fish deeper or into slower water. Dam release schedules can also affect fishing quality, since increased flow stirs up baitfish and triggers feeding. Arriving before sunrise gives you the best chance at active fish before boat traffic and heat set in.
The Mounds Area on Brookville Lake is a solid choice for beginners and families since it offers calm lake conditions and a good population of panfish like bluegill that are forgiving for newer anglers. The Tailwater Shelters involve fishing in moving water below a dam, which adds some complexity around reading current and adjusting weight, making it better suited to anglers with at least some river fishing experience. Both areas have accessible shelter structures, which helps when fishing with kids who need breaks from the sun.
