Loading trail…
Indiana · Fishing
Bloomington sits within easy reach of three distinct lake fishing options, each with a different character and crowd level.
3 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 3 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Bloomington sits within easy reach of three distinct lake fishing options, each with a different character and crowd level. Lake Monroe is the biggest draw — it's the largest inland lake in Indiana and holds largemouth bass, crappie, catfish, and walleye, with enough water that you can find a quiet cove even on a summer weekend. Paynetown, on the northeastern shore of Monroe, is one of the more popular access points and has a boat ramp and shoreline spots that work well if you're fishing without a boat. Griffy Reservoir is the local sleeper — a smaller, quieter body of water closer to town that's managed by the city of Bloomington and offers a more low-key experience, particularly for anglers who want to walk the banks rather than launch a boat. None of these are trophy-designated or gold-medal waters, but they're productive, accessible, and genuinely fishable year-round if you adjust your approach by season. Whether you're rigging up for the first time or just looking for a reliable spot to spend a morning, Bloomington's lake fishing options cover a reasonable range of what most freshwater anglers are after.
Both spots have fishable shoreline access, and Paynetown in particular is set up well for bank anglers with open areas along the water. That said, a boat opens up a lot more of Lake Monroe's structure — points, coves, and submerged timber — where bass and crappie tend to hold. If you don't have a boat, focus on Paynetown's accessible shoreline or try Griffy Reservoir, which is well-suited to walking the banks.
Lake Monroe holds largemouth bass, crappie, bluegill, channel catfish, and walleye. Griffy Reservoir is known more for bass and bluegill. All three are lake fisheries, so you're working warmwater species — don't come expecting trout unless you're fishing during a specific stocking event, and stocking schedules should be confirmed with the Indiana DNR before your trip.
Lake Monroe
~5 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
East Fork White River at Williams Dam
~34 min drive
Moderate
Starve Hollow Lake
~47 min drive
Easy
Paynetown
~6 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Cagles Mill Lake (Lieber SRA)
~1h 7m drive
Easy
Griffy Reservoir
~10 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Hardy Lake
~1h 20m drive
Easy
Ogle Lake
~19 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Pine Ridge Pond
~32 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Lake Edgewood
~38 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Amazon Lake
~38 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Grouse Ridge Lake
~38 min drive
A worthwhile stop near IN.
Early morning and the last two hours before sunset are consistently the most productive windows, especially for bass in warmer months when fish move shallow to feed. Midday in summer tends to push fish deeper and into shade. For crappie and catfish on Lake Monroe, night fishing around structure can be effective in late spring and summer.
You need a valid Indiana fishing license, which you can purchase through the Indiana DNR website or at local retailers. Griffy Reservoir has specific rules set by the city of Bloomington — including restrictions on motorized boats — so check current regulations directly with the city before you go. Lake Monroe falls under standard DNR rules, but slot limits and size restrictions on certain species can change, so verify before your trip.
Yes, especially Griffy Reservoir and the shoreline areas at Paynetown. Both offer calm, accessible water without the boat traffic you'll encounter on busier parts of Lake Monroe. Bluegill are abundant and easy to catch on simple rigs, which makes these spots practical for younger anglers or anyone just getting started. Paynetown also has facilities nearby, which helps if you're bringing a family.
