Connecticut · Fishing
Fishing in Old Lyme, Connecticut
Old Lyme sits at the mouth of the Connecticut River, but the fishing that draws most locals isn't tidal — it's the cluster of still-water ponds and lakes tucked into the town's wooded interior.
6 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 6 spots
Old Lyme sits at the mouth of the Connecticut River, but the fishing that draws most locals isn't tidal — it's the cluster of still-water ponds and lakes tucked into the town's wooded interior. Rogers Lake is the largest and most accessible of the bunch, with a public boat launch and enough depth to hold fish through the summer heat. Tinker Pond, Gunning Swamp, Upper Millpond, and Duck Pond round out the options, each offering a quieter, more intimate experience than the bigger water. These are predominantly warmwater fisheries — think largemouth bass, yellow perch, and pickerel — suited to anglers who know how to work structure and vegetation rather than chasing current. The pace here is unhurried. You're not fighting crowds or navigating complicated access logistics; you're picking a pond, launching a kayak or casting from the bank, and working the edges. Spring and fall are the most productive seasons across all of these waters, and a basic Connecticut freshwater fishing license covers you for all of them. Whether you're a first-timer learning to read still water or a seasoned bass angler looking for a low-pressure morning, Old Lyme's ponds offer more variety than their modest size suggests.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a license to fish Rogers Lake or the other ponds in Old Lyme?
Yes, a Connecticut Inland Fishing License is required for anyone 16 or older fishing any of these waters, including Rogers Lake, Tinker Pond, Gunning Swamp, Upper Millpond, and Duck Pond. Licenses can be purchased online through the Connecticut DEEP website or at local bait and tackle shops. Check the current DEEP regulations booklet for any site-specific rules before you go.
What fish species can I expect to catch in these waters?
These are warmwater lakes and ponds, so largemouth bass, chain pickerel, and yellow perch are the most common targets. Bluegill and other sunfish are abundant and make for good light-tackle fishing, especially in shallower ponds like Duck Pond and Gunning Swamp. Rogers Lake, being the deepest and largest, also holds white perch and the occasional smallmouth bass.
What is the best time of day to fish these ponds?
Early morning and the last two hours before sunset are consistently the most productive windows, particularly for bass and pickerel. During summer, midday fishing slows significantly as fish push into deeper, cooler water or hold tight to shaded structure. Spring mornings on Rogers Lake and Tinker Pond can be especially active as fish move into the shallows to spawn.
Can I use a motorboat on Rogers Lake, or are these paddle-only waters?
Rogers Lake allows motorized boats, though Connecticut has horsepower restrictions on many inland lakes, so verify the current limit with DEEP before trailering a larger vessel. The smaller ponds in Old Lyme — including Tinker Pond, Duck Pond, and Gunning Swamp — are better suited to canoes, kayaks, and small car-top boats. A kayak or canoe is honestly the most practical choice across all six of these fisheries.
Is this a good destination for beginner anglers or families with kids?
Yes, particularly Duck Pond and the shallower sections of Tinker Pond, where bluegill and sunfish are easy to find and will take a simple worm-and-bobber setup. Rogers Lake has a proper boat launch and enough open shoreline for bank fishing, which makes it manageable for families. The fishing here doesn't require specialized gear or advanced technique, and the lack of significant boat traffic on most of these ponds keeps things relaxed.
