Loading trail…
Colorado · Fishing
Greeley sits on the high plains of northern Colorado, and while it's not the first place most anglers think of when they picture Colorado fishing, the city has a handful of accessible stillwater spots that are worth knowing about.
4 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 4 spots
No additional spots match this filter.
Greeley sits on the high plains of northern Colorado, and while it's not the first place most anglers think of when they picture Colorado fishing, the city has a handful of accessible stillwater spots that are worth knowing about. The four lakes and reservoirs in and around town — Arrowhead Reservoir, Glenmere Lake, Bittersweet Lake, and Darling Reservoir — are all lake fisheries, meaning you're working the bank or a float tube rather than wading a river. That changes the approach considerably: still water rewards patience, early mornings, and an understanding of where fish hold as temperatures shift through the day. These are community-accessible waters, which makes them a reasonable option for families, beginners, or anyone who wants a low-commitment outing without driving into the mountains. Expect a more casual fishing experience than you'd find on a designated wild trout stream — these are plains lakes, not gold-medal water — but that doesn't mean they're empty. With the right timing and a basic setup, you can have a productive morning. If you're coming from out of town specifically to fish, it's worth pairing a Greeley stop with other northern Colorado waters, but for locals or visitors already in the area, these spots are genuinely fishable.
The lakes in Greeley — Glenmere, Bittersweet, Arrowhead Reservoir, and Darling Reservoir — are plains stillwater fisheries, so you're most likely looking at warm-water species like bass, bluegill, and possibly catfish or carp. Check with Colorado Parks and Wildlife for current stocking reports on specific waters, since stocking schedules and species can change season to season.
Yes, anyone 16 or older needs a valid Colorado fishing license to fish any of these waters. You can purchase one online through Colorado Parks and Wildlife or at local sporting goods retailers. Some waters may have additional local regulations, so it's worth confirming access rules for each specific lake before you go.
Glenmere Lake
~1 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Bittersweet Lake
~3 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Riverside Park lake
~6 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Arrowhead Reservoir
~7 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Darling Reservoir
~9 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Woods Lake
~15 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Ehrlich Lake
~17 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Severence City Pond
~19 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Eaton-Law Reservoir
~20 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Little Thompson Reservoir
~20 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Windsor Reservoir
~21 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Jodee Reservoir
~23 min drive
A worthwhile stop near CO.
Early morning is consistently the most productive window on stillwater lakes like these, especially in summer when midday heat pushes fish deeper and slows surface activity. Late evening is a solid second option. If you're fishing in spring or fall when water temperatures are cooler, midday can be productive too.
A medium-action spinning rod in the 6- to 7-foot range handles most situations on these lakes. For warm-water species, soft plastics, small jigs, and live bait like worms or nightcrawlers are reliable choices. If you're fishing from the bank rather than a float tube or kayak, focus on casting toward any visible structure — points, inlets, or vegetation edges — rather than open water.
Yes, these are among the more beginner-friendly fishing options in the area precisely because they're local, flat, and don't require hiking or wading. Glenmere Lake in particular is a city park lake with easy bank access. Bring simple gear, keep expectations realistic, and early morning on a weekday will give you the quietest experience.
