Arizona · Fishing
Fishing in Nutrioso, Arizona
Nutrioso sits in the White Mountains of eastern Arizona at around 8,000 feet, and the fishing here is almost entirely still-water fishing — lakes, reservoirs, and tanks scattered across the surrounding Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest.
17 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 17 spots
Nutrioso sits in the White Mountains of eastern Arizona at around 8,000 feet, and the fishing here is almost entirely still-water fishing — lakes, reservoirs, and tanks scattered across the surrounding Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest. The area has more options than most people expect: Saint Marys Lake, Hulsey Lake, Nelson Reservoir, Rogers Reservoir, Nutrioso Reservoir, Lake Sierra Blanca, San Salvador Reservoir, and smaller spots like Turkey Tank and H-V Reservoir all sit within reasonable driving distance of town. Most of these waters are stocked by Arizona Game and Fish, so the fishing calendar tracks closely with stocking schedules rather than wild fish behavior. That said, the high elevation keeps water temperatures cool through summer, which means fish stay active longer into the day than they would at lower-elevation Arizona lakes. Access ranges from easy pull-up spots at Nelson Reservoir to rougher dirt-road approaches at some of the smaller tanks, so it's worth checking road conditions before you load the truck. A valid Arizona fishing license is required at all of these waters, and some sites on National Forest land have additional day-use considerations worth confirming before you go.
Frequently asked questions
What species can I expect to catch at these lakes and reservoirs?
Arizona Game and Fish stocks most of the waters around Nutrioso with rainbow trout, and some of the larger reservoirs like Nelson and Lake Sierra Blanca also hold warm-water species including bass and catfish. The smaller tanks tend to be trout-focused when recently stocked. Check the AZGFD stocking report before your trip since smaller waters can fish out quickly after a stocking event.
When is the best time of year to fish near Nutrioso?
Spring and fall are the most productive seasons. Stocking activity typically picks up in spring once ice-off happens and again in fall before the water gets too cold. Summer fishing is workable because the elevation keeps water temperatures down, but you'll want to be on the water early morning before afternoon monsoon storms roll in, which are common from July through September.
What gear should I bring for lake and reservoir fishing here?
Light to medium spinning tackle covers most situations. For stocked trout, small spinners, PowerBait, and worms on a simple slip-sinker rig are reliable producers. If you're targeting bass at the larger reservoirs, bring a few soft plastics and small crankbaits. A pair of waders isn't essential at most of these spots since bank access is generally decent, but rubber boots help at marshy edges like Rogers Marsh.
Do I need a special permit beyond an Arizona fishing license?
A standard Arizona fishing license covers you at the state and National Forest waters listed here. Some of the smaller tanks may sit on private or tribal land adjacent to the forest, so it's worth confirming access and ownership before you drive out to a remote spot. The AZGFD website and the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest office in Springerville can both answer access questions specific to a given water.
Are these spots suitable for kids or beginners?
Several of them are. Nelson Reservoir and Hulsey Lake have relatively easy bank access and are stocked regularly, which makes them good choices for younger anglers or people new to fishing who benefit from active fish. The smaller tanks like Turkey Tank and Sut Tank are more remote and better suited to anglers comfortable navigating dirt roads and fishing without amenities nearby.
